Most comfortable high heel shoes 2016

Last updated June 14, 2021

High heels is a very beautiful footwear for any woman. If you want to get a lot of compliments and look awesome on a birthday, wedding, Valentine’s day or any other special occasion then you must wear high heels. But we all know how difficult it is to wear shoes with high heels.

This year we did the research and compiled the list of the most comfortable pumps that are easy to walk in, affordable and available for purchase right now.

Product Price Heel height Good for Widest size Overall score
Wild Diva Women's Adora 126 Pointy Toe Lace Up Ankle Tie Studded High Heel Wild Diva Women's Adora 126 Pointy Toe Lace Up Ankle Tie Studded High Heel $13.41 - $39.99 4" Great shoes for a night out. M 4,5
Top Moda Hy-5 Open Toe Crochet High Heel Sandals Top Moda Hy-5 Open Toe Crochet High Heel Sandals $16.66 - $34.95 4.5" Perfect wedding shoes.
The ankle strap and the platform make them comfortable to wear all day.
M 4,5
Ollio Women's Shoe Platform Open Toe High Heel Ribbon Accent Multi Color Pump Ollio Women's Shoe Platform Open Toe High Heel Ribbon Accent Multi Color Pump $24.99 - $33.99 4.92" Beautiful platform shoes with very high heels. Suitable for wearing on occasions for several hours. M 4,4
Comfort Plus by Predictions Women's Karmen Pump Comfort Plus by Predictions Women's Karmen Pump $15.00 - $29.99 3" Cute comfortable shoes for standing all day. Also made in extra wide sizes. C/D 4,4
Classy Mary Jane Double Ankle Strap Almond Toe High Heel Pumps Classy Mary Jane Double Ankle Strap Almond Toe High Heel Pumps $17.99 - $34.99 4" Platform shoes with high heels and straps. Comfortable to wear for several hours. M 4,4
Breckelles Isabel-01 D-Orsay Pumps-Shoes Breckelles Isabel-01 D-Orsay Pumps-Shoes $14.99 - $68.00 4" Comfortable stylish office shoes. M 4,3
Pointed Toe Ankle Strap D'Orsay High Heel Stiletto Pumps Pointed Toe Ankle Strap D'Orsay High Heel Stiletto Pumps $18.99 - $34.99 4" Pretty shoes to wear out for several hours. M 4,3
Clarks Women's Brier Dolly Dress Pump Clarks Women's Brier Dolly Dress Pump $44.99 - $118.00 3.25" Super comfortable pumps with round-toe and ortholite footbed. Can be worn all day. Perfect for work in the office. C/D 4,3

The most comfortable heels to wear in our test is Wild Diva Women’s Adora Pointy Toe High Heel. They have an ankle strap for an extra support and are great shoes to wear a night out. For all day wear the best shoes are Top Moda Open Toe Crochet High Heel Sandals or Comfort Plus by Predictions Karmen Pump.

The most comfortable heels we could find is a pair of Ollio Women’s High Heel Ribbon Accent Pump with a height of 4.92 inches (12 cm). They have a thick platform, so the height of the heel is not so tall.

How to choose comfortable heels

Many shoes look awesome, but when you try them on they are not comfortable at all. Here are some tips to check that will help you determine if the pump is good to walk in:

  1. The shoe fits both in length and width. This is more important for high heel shoes as you will need to balance so the shoe must be a good fit.
  2. The heel is not too far back. If the heel is too far back than the shoe won’t support your weight properly and the center of balance will be misplaced forward. This will force you to lean forward and curve your back while walking. Ideally the center of the shoe heel should be right under you own heel.
    valentino brasil pump
  3. Straps. The strap support and keep your foot in place while you walk so you don’t need to flex your foot in order to hold the shoe. The straps make the process of walking in high heel shoes much easier.
  4. The shoe’s toe material cover the toes completely. For example, almost all Christian Louboutin shoes are rather uncomfortable to walk in.
    Amazon
  5. Thicker sole. Shoes with high heels are much more comfortable with a little bit more cushion at the bottom as the toes bear all the weight of your body. If your shoes doesn’t have a platform try adding a gel insoles or forefoot pads.
    Amazon

Scratches and scuffs

Nice pair of shoes may still get scratched and scuffed even though you wear them carefully. If the outer material of your shoe is very thin, then every scratch will show right through in a very obvious way.

In case of scratches try to touch them up with a permanent marker, liquid leather color pen or shoe polish (not for patent leather).

Scuffs are removed depending on a shoe material type.

Comfortable high heels for wide feet

Many high heel shoes will be comfortable for wide feet naturally especially if they are made of real leather. Leather is a very stretchy material and this will make the shoe fit perfectly after it is broken in.

For people with very wide feet we found several super comfy high heels: Comfort Plus by Predictions Women’s Karmen Pump and Clarks Women’s Brier Dolly Dress Pump. Both are sold in C/D width as well as normal (M) width. Clarks are made of leather and may be stretched even more out.

Expensive heels

Our research show that expensive heels are not more comfortable than regular priced ones. On the contrary, designer shoes like Christian Louboutin or Valentin are more difficult to wear and are more a “sitting and photography” shoes than regular wear. Christian says it himself in this interview on CBS:

The most expensive comfortable shoes in our test are Clarks pumps and cost up to $118.00.

Small sizes

We didn’t find any very comfy high heels size 4 or less. There are some beautiful heels for women with small feet.